RockStarYoga
  • perspective: why
  • musings
  • teaching: where, when + which
  • private yoga
  • rasayana: bodywork
  • mentoring + mental arts
  • ceremony + ritual
  • bio: who + what
  • education: what + how
  • connect: talk to me
  • snapshots
    • Yoga Advance - Isla Mujeres 2014
    • Rockstarring
    • Planet K
    • Play-asana
    • Students, Teachers, Friends, Inspirations
    • Easter Island, Patagonia, Chile
    • Turkey, Anatolia, Cappadocia
    • Isla Mujeres
    • Tulum, Yucatan, Coba
  • videos
  • offerings

A response to yesterday's NPR story on the NYT story -

9/2/2012

1 Comment

 
It is very difficult for me - total disclosure - to take anything the  "Pulitzer-Prize winning science writer for the NYT" says seriously or as informed when in the fourth paragraph (link included below) he indicates that while practicing shoulderstand  and plow (Salamba Sarvangasana and Halasana), and I quote - "you're  rotating your neck around 90 degrees..."

Actually, I would  expect a science writer, who has studied physiology and yoga and deigns  to write about it would understand that rotation and flexion are two  quite distinct spinal movements and that the postures that he is talking about indicate a flexed cervical spine, but no rotation (to be fair, it is absolutely a way for a student to hurt themselves if they choose to 'look around' and rotate their neck in Shoulderstand - that's a truism, but not what he is discussing).
 
It's  quite simple - turn your head over your right shoulder, you've quite  possibly been able to safely rotate your head up to 90 degrees... drop  your chin to your chest, you've quite possibly been able to flex your  neck approaching 90 degrees.

Of course, in an inversion, with  the added gravity, for 90% of casual practitioners, Shoulderstand is contraindicated. But, somehow a man who is trying to inform us all about the dangers of a yoga teacher who has such limited training in anatomy - one of many commentators biggest concerns is the 'limited amount of anatomy' that is studied, and to be fair, 20 hours is not a lot to learn if you start from scratch and intend to guide physical movement. However, for a science writer who seeks to be published and comment from his authority, he obviously is not coming from a place of information, experience, or investigation (former hallmarks of journalism, abandoned almost completely in modern media). 
 
Very troubling - and, in my estimation, low-leverage fear-mongering, limbic-system engaging panic is not informative or elevating. This conversation can be rational and based in truth, but that was not the impression that is given... seems like he wants to help sell a book and now is enjoying his time in the light.

No dispute that there are many, many, unsophisticated  or less than talented teachers out there. Apparently, the same can be  said about journalists.

Here's my advice - grill your teacher, ask them their background, their practice, their training, how long since their last training, what is their intention in teaching, have they studied anatomy further than the minimum expectation?? If you are pleasant, and inquisitive and get answers and have a dialog, that's in everyone's benefit. If the teacher is shocked, not responsive or defensive, you have all the answers you'll ever need there!

No effort on this path is wasted - effort is not pain, effort is not excessiveness - effort is presence and intention.

GIve thanks and praise - multitudes are healed and blessed; few are harmed, and those who pay attention will know the difference.

The Risks And Rewards Of Practicing Yoga : NPR
1 Comment
Tina
9/2/2012 06:59:09 am

I'm by no means a yoga expert, but this guy really hit a nerve with me yesterday. I lost respect and interest the moment he stated his injury amounted from "strutting his stuff" in an "advanced class" and not paying attention when his "attractive" partner was working with him on a side angle pose and ended up leaning too far over while chatting with her. Yoga wasn't responsible for his injury. So much wrong in all of that. I've never been to a class where the teacher didn't say "mind your body". It's your responsibility to listen.

Anyway, the interview went downhill (if that was even possible) from there. I just got the impression that he's cashing in on the yoga explosion. Which is unfortunate. It's also unfortunate that there are people who listened to it who will put faith in this one single source.

Sad panda.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Picture

    Chrispy - Bhagat Singh

    Random thoughts I've had, while teaching, about the teachings, about my teaching, and while talking about teaching.

    Connect with me:
    Facebook: 
    chrispy bhagat singh
     Facebook:
    RockStarYoga
    Facebook:
    RaSaYana
    YouTube:

    chrispy bhagat singh
    Instagram:
    petrastella
    Twitter: 
    petrastella

    Email: 
    rockstar@rockstaryoga.us

    Picture

    Archives

    July 2015
    May 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013
    January 2013
    December 2012
    November 2012
    October 2012
    September 2012
    August 2012
    July 2012
    June 2012
    May 2012
    April 2012
    March 2012
    February 2012

    Categories

    All
    Anusara
    Asana
    Asana Practice
    Brain
    Calendar
    Chakras
    Challenge
    Collaboration
    Community
    Compassion
    Discernment
    Experience
    Happiness
    Holy Days
    Lent
    Love
    Magic
    Mindfulness
    Nyt
    Observance
    Patanjali
    Practice
    Resources
    Shadow
    Shine
    Sutras
    Teachers
    Teaching
    Yoga

    Picture
Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.